Lot 666

Previous image preload Next image preload

Description:

Early American silver punch bowl of Southern interest, possibly Charleston Huguenot silversmith Isaac Peronneau South Carolina or New York, circa 1750
banded rim on flared round bowl resting on ring base; design similar to Paul Revere; the side engraved LOGAN, CHARLESTON S.C., 1720; underside marked: IP within plain square, and engraved initials CDL.
H4 1/4" Dia.8 3/4", and 19.5oz troy

Provenance: Missouri private collection.

Literature: Burton, E. Milby and Ripley, Warren. SOUTH CAROLINA SILVERSMITHS, 1690-1860. Charleston: Charleston Museum, 1991. pp.76-7.

Ensko, Stephen. AMERICAN SILVERSMITHS AND THEIR MARKS. Boston, Godine, 1989. pp.285.

Logan, George William. A RECORD OF THE LOGAN FAMILY OF CHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA. Sacrameto: Record Books and Jobs Printing Office, 1874.

Other Notes: This bowl marked IP could be attributed to several Colonial American silversmiths who are known to have worked in the second half of the 18th century. Current research shows that silversmiths in South Carolina, Maryland, New York, and Massachusetts, all marked their wares with the IP; however the Northern silversmith's known marks differ by the use of pellet or crown over initials and some are encased within a shield rather than a square. Interestingly enough, the literature on Charleston Huguenot silversmith Isaac Peronneau (working 1743) has two intriguing notations posted from the South Carolina Gazette. The first is an announcement printed in the fall of 1750, which reads "To be run for On the second Monday in November next, if a fair day, and if not the first fair day after, at the house of Mr. Isaac Peronneau in Goose Creek, a three pint silver TANKARD, and a silver PUNCH BOWL, value Two Hundred and Fifty Pounds, by any nine mares, horses, and geldings, to run a quarter of a mile and catch riders. Three horses to run together and the foremost to be put aside till the others run; and afterwards the three best to run, and the foremost horse to win the prize…" The second entry notes a South Carolina Gazette advertisement placed by David Brown on 22 February 1752, "Stolen in January last, out of the subscriber's house, supposed by a negro, two silver table spoons, one markt [sic] T::C with three stamps near the bowl, thus IP". There was yet another silversmith working in Charleston at this time named John Pennefather (working 1736-40); there are no notations as to what his marks may have been or what he may have made. As for the New York silversmith John Pearson, this bowl appears to have been made somewhat earlier than his working dates of 1791-1805, and there is no evidence that Pearson produced any bowls.

The engraved dedication LOGAN, CHARLESTON S.C., 1720 is of a later date, as the engraving style is not consistent with 18th century techniques, and the use of the present day spelling of Charleston was not adopted until after 1783. The Logan family arrived in Charleston in the 1690's from Scotland, and the significance of the 1720 date has not been determined.

    Condition:
  • Top rim has a 2-inch vertical repair; and the base appears to have been mended. The bowl had small dents and blemish throughout.


Accepted Forms of Payment:

Money Order / Cashiers Check, Other, Personal Check, Wire Transfer

Shipping

CHARLTON HALL DOES NOT SHIP: Charlton Hall will be pleased to provide a list of shippers and packers that will our worldwide base of clients has successfully used, or you can have your own shipper handle your purchases. Please contact the shipper of your choice to arrange for packing and pick up your items. Your items will be released as soon as payment cleans our bank. We requests that your shippers schedule pick up times at least 24 hours in advance, this will insure no delays in pick up, and release of your purchases.

March 7, 2010 1:00 PM EST
West Columbia, SC, US

Charlton Hall

You agree to pay a buyer's premium of up to 18% and any applicable taxes and shipping.

View full terms and conditions

Bid Increments
From: To: Increments:
$0 $99 $10
$100 $499 $25
$500 $999 $50
$1,000 $2,999 $100
$3,000 $4,999 $200
$5,000 $9,999 $500
$10,000 $19,999 $1,000
$20,000 $49,999 $2,000
$50,000 + $5,000